We all know the catch-phrase of the American Revolution: "No Taxation Without Representation!" I remember watching School House Rock in 6th grade and hearing this phrase over and over again. My impression then was that most of the colonists were fed up with how Britain was handling the colonies. They shouldn't have to be taxed for things like tea if they can't even vote and participate in the government that's making these decisions.
Reading "Unruly Americans" by Woody Holten made me think differently. Sure many colonists were miffed about taxes. But the "Founding Fathers", those who had the most influence on the British government and society at that time, had other reasons as well for becoming an independent nation. The British government drew the Proclamation Line, which represented the boundary that colonists couldn't pass or settle past. This was mostly a safety and economic issue, since the Native Americans could rebel against the colonists if they came too close to their land or flat out conquered it. Having this boundary meant that the colonists couldn't expand indefinitely or increase their wealth.
Wealthy colonists suggested getting free grants from the British government to buy and then sell or rent new land, and thus make more money. In the Declaration of Independence there is only one mention of taxation and three statements about acquiring more land. Whie common people didn't want the burden of taxes, the wealthy had other motives for rebellion.
I've always been an American, but it's hard to know what that means. Am I a part of culture and is it part of me? How does being American define me as a person? Even if I moved to another country, could I detach myself from everything that is "America"? Let's find out.
Thursday, November 4, 2010
Monday, November 1, 2010
Tea and Social Class
In Britain in the 1700's and after, tea was a kind of equalizer among the different social classes. In the 1730's Britain started trading directly with China, and the price of tea went down because of it. This meant that even those in the lower class could afford tea. Some historians argue that few of the people in the lower class actually had tea, but tea became a commodity that some of the poor really enjoyed having, and were willing to budget for purchasing tea and sugar. Since people of all classes drank tea, they could also offer it to anyone else without offending them or feeling out of place. The ceremony involved with preparing and drinking tea forced the drinker to slow down and relax for awhile. Both the rich and the poor enjoyed their time drinking tea with their family because everyone was together and tea was mild enough for children to have. Today that important time of togetherness may be weekday dinners. Our lives are so busy that we need a tradition, a set time to relax and enjoy the company of our family and friends. The working class enjoyed tea breaks with friends because it was something to look forward to, a time to complain about work and mingle. Tea breaks resemble today's coffee breaks in the corporate world.
As much as tea was an equalizer, it also magnified differences in class and rank. The kind of porcelain ware you had determined how much money you had and what you were able to afford. Some teas were more expensive than others, and extra ingredients like milk, sugar, and honey had their expense. There were certain ways to pour and hold your cup of tea, down to the last detail of how you hold your finger out while taking a sip (Macfarlane 86). Since having tea and its accessories would show status, many people started buying them to show off their status and give a certain impression. This is just like how today people buy clothes, cars, and food that reflect how well off they are and what they value.
As much as tea was an equalizer, it also magnified differences in class and rank. The kind of porcelain ware you had determined how much money you had and what you were able to afford. Some teas were more expensive than others, and extra ingredients like milk, sugar, and honey had their expense. There were certain ways to pour and hold your cup of tea, down to the last detail of how you hold your finger out while taking a sip (Macfarlane 86). Since having tea and its accessories would show status, many people started buying them to show off their status and give a certain impression. This is just like how today people buy clothes, cars, and food that reflect how well off they are and what they value.
Friday, October 29, 2010
dense facts are frustrating
In class today we dove into the idea of a dense fact. We've been "dense facting" during the whole semester with things like tea, Pocahontas, and Rockwell's Four Freedoms. In class we started expanding the idea of a dense fact to people, places, things, or ideas. This includes both the concrete and the abstract. We started questioning whether things like climate change or fear could be a dense fact. We spent less time talking about what the Tea Party is all about, which was disappointing. I don't think our conversation was even that helpful in figuring out what to write about for our editorial, since it seems like practically anything can be a dense fact. It shouldn't matter if something is a dense fact or not; if it's interesting, then let's talk about it! Limiting our analysis to certain images or objects can also limit our thinking, since we're trying to figure our what the dense fact represents or stands for. Since readings have been most helpful to me in this class so far, I'm going to stick to them and the content they provide, rather than just my opinions about the Tea Party.
Wednesday, October 27, 2010
Franklin's Faith
What Benjamin Franklin went through with his faith is something that many people experience: a want of personal spirituality and faith, without the rites and doctrines telling one how to live life the right way. Franklin says that he never doubted, "...the existence of the Deity...that the most acceptable service to God was the doing good to man; that our souls are immortal; and that all crime will be punished, and virtue rewarded, either here or hereafter" (62). There were times when he went to church and publicly displayed his faith, and times when he didn't. Then again, religion and spirituality are two very different things, as I see it. Spirituality seems to be a very personal experience with something outside or larger than oneself, like God, whereas religion is the outward appearance and manifestation of this relationship and one's beliefs.
Although I'm not a Deist, I can relate to Franklin because I've felt some of the same things about religion. As much as I know what I believe, it's still hard to be told what the one right way is, especially when many people or groups think their way is right. It makes me uncomfortable when religion is used as both a sword and a shield, as justification and defense for doing something that's otherwise seen as wrong. People sometimes use God to protect themselves from dispute or critique. I believe in God, but sometimes in a slightly different way than how official religions groups or politicians do.
Although I'm not a Deist, I can relate to Franklin because I've felt some of the same things about religion. As much as I know what I believe, it's still hard to be told what the one right way is, especially when many people or groups think their way is right. It makes me uncomfortable when religion is used as both a sword and a shield, as justification and defense for doing something that's otherwise seen as wrong. People sometimes use God to protect themselves from dispute or critique. I believe in God, but sometimes in a slightly different way than how official religions groups or politicians do.
Tuesday, October 26, 2010
Benjamin Franklin and Humility
In his autobiography, Franklin explains his personal virtues, a set of beliefs that can be turned into action. One he mentions often is humility. While he has always tried to be humble in his writing, never using words such as "certainly" or "undoubtedly", he still struggled with his pride as a great writer. His friends had great respect for him and his ideas, but reminded him of how sure he was of himself, and how that put them off. In his list of virtues to practice, Franklin's last is humility and he suggests to "...imitate Jesus and Socrates" (Franklin 65). It's interesting that he mentions these two people because as a Christian and a scientist, they were very important in his life. However much he tried to be a humble man, he still struggled, as we all do. He argues that he can try to control his pride, but it will surface from time to time and, "...even if [he] could conceive that [he] had completely overcome it, [he] should probably be proud of [his] humility" (Franklin 72). Humility ties into his goal of self-improvement. This means finding one's flaws and weaknesses, trying to improve upon them, and always accepting advice and help to become a better version of yourself. Even though people can't reach true perfection, however one defines it, it is worth it to try because one becomes a better person who can make the world better too.
Friday, October 22, 2010
Buying Locally
Today in class we talked about Paul Revere and what his portrait says about him and the culture and people of his time. He was probably a middle upper class gentleman because he had a respectable trade, yet did not have a lot of decorative or ornate clothing or furniture to show his status. Someone mentioned that the portrait makes him look like an average citizen, a familiar face. People would see this painting and think, "Hey, he looks like my local silversmith". Then we talked about the value of buying a product locally or from overseas, and if it is worth it to buy local or not.
For me, the environmental consequences of buying most products from overseas is enough to want to buy locally. This is especially important for food because so much energy is used and wastede in food production, preservation, and transportation. Also, we get much of our energy from the Middle East, so if we produced more sustainable energy in the U.S. we would not only be a more independant and safer country, but one that provides more jobs to people too.
Usually I know I just buy something based on the price. If one product is similar to another but is cheaper, I'll buy it. But since you often "get what you pay for", the quality may not be the best and the conditions under which it was made may be lesser than the product that cost more.
For me, the environmental consequences of buying most products from overseas is enough to want to buy locally. This is especially important for food because so much energy is used and wastede in food production, preservation, and transportation. Also, we get much of our energy from the Middle East, so if we produced more sustainable energy in the U.S. we would not only be a more independant and safer country, but one that provides more jobs to people too.
Usually I know I just buy something based on the price. If one product is similar to another but is cheaper, I'll buy it. But since you often "get what you pay for", the quality may not be the best and the conditions under which it was made may be lesser than the product that cost more.
Wednesday, October 20, 2010
So. Much. Stuff.
Even though I really tried to minimize how much stuff I brought to school, I'm still overwhelmed at what I brought. Granted most of it is necessary, like clothes, bedding, and toiletries, a lot of it isn't really needed. I've got my Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter collection dvds, lots of scarves and jewelry, letters and pictures from home, as well as plenty of munchies. This says a lot about me, that I like to watch movies with friends, express myself with clothes, spend time with my family, and of course eat delicious snacks.
Life would be much different if we lived in colonial times. I would only have what I absolutely need. I wouldn't have to think about what to wear or what kind of entertainment to choose, because there just wouldn't be too many options. That is one reason why I like camping and being surrounded by nature. You only have what you need, nothing else. You're just doing what you have to do to be safe and comfortable enough to enjoy the outdoors. Now coming back from break I see all the stuff in my room and I wonder "How did I get it all in here?? Thank goodness for Hoyme's amazing shelving space." Whenever I de-clutter or take things home I don't need or use, I feel rejuvenated because all it does is take up space. Living more simply can give great peace of mind.
Life would be much different if we lived in colonial times. I would only have what I absolutely need. I wouldn't have to think about what to wear or what kind of entertainment to choose, because there just wouldn't be too many options. That is one reason why I like camping and being surrounded by nature. You only have what you need, nothing else. You're just doing what you have to do to be safe and comfortable enough to enjoy the outdoors. Now coming back from break I see all the stuff in my room and I wonder "How did I get it all in here?? Thank goodness for Hoyme's amazing shelving space." Whenever I de-clutter or take things home I don't need or use, I feel rejuvenated because all it does is take up space. Living more simply can give great peace of mind.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)